Sunday, December 18, 2011

To The Extreme

Not That One
courtesy of Jim Crossley-raindog
If you thought that I was going to break into a Vanilla Ice song after reading the title to this post, then I apologize. I did however find it a little humorous that the line "collaborate and listen" was in Ice Ice Baby, maybe Vanilla was a bit ahead of his time. But on a serious note, I have been pondering lately why everything seems to be to the extreme, education reform, leadership style, politics, couponing. Rarely these days do you see push, pull, "off balance on purpose" situations that challenge and take staff to the edge, but not completely push them off the cliff. I would argue that disruption, innovation, pushing adults and students can take place with great results without an entire staff/class ending up at the bottom of the canyon.

Off Balance
How many times have you heard that to much of any one thing is not a good idea? The pressure to perform in the K-12 arena seems to push ideas to the extreme and one giant weight is dropped on the balance scale, with no hope of returning to the off balance place that is desired. In Dan Thurmon's book, "Off Balance On Purpose," he writes:

courtesy of christart.com
When we experience imbalance in our lives, we often overcompensate by throwing ourselves in another direction. We think that it takes bold, dramatic action to create change. Sometimes this is true-we reach moments in our lives when a huge shift in thinking or action is completely necessary. But usually when we find ourselves in that predicament, it is because we missed many previous opportunities to make smaller adjustments that would have prevented, or at least softened, the crisis. Often an attempt to overdo it, providing to much force in one direction or another to quickly, will only exacerbate the trouble. -Dan Thurmon

The same thought can be applied to organizations that are struggling to be successful and looking for the magic bullet of change. Instead of looking at the foundational issues within, a bold, dramatic action takes place that results in the scale being tipped completely over.

Technology Balance
I think we often tip the scale to the extreme with technology initiatives as a silver bullet approach, missing the foundational pieces that will truly make using technology in our classrooms relevant. Take a look at all the 1:1 initiatives that have struggled over the years because the focus was on the shiny new object and not:                           

-Good teaching
-Professional Dev
-Digital Citizenship
-Parent involvement
-Infrastructure
-Sustainability

An example of going to the extreme in a 1:1 environment would be piling up every book on campus and having a giant bonfire to celebrate every student having a device. Sure this would afford the ability to eliminate certain texts and some paper use that is not necessary, but a successful 1:1 isn't measured by walking into a classroom and every student having a device open in front of them. We need to think about being off balance enough to sustain meaningful change, without pushing the entire group to the bottom of the canyon for the sake of a photo op. 

Welcome Change
I enjoy change and new things, maybe that is why I don't like riding the same exact trail every day on my bike, or listening to the same music on repeat for a year at a time, I even enjoy clipping a coupon now and again. Speaking of coupons, before creating a stockpile that turns into an episode on hoarding, ask yourself if you are off balance or just going to the extreme for that photo op.

2 comments:

  1. Hi Jon,

    I love the quote about focusing on the shiny new object, instead of pedagogy, professional development, digital citizenship, community development, infrastructure, & sustainability.

    There always needs to be a balance, and keeping the focus on the learning. I remember the first school I taught at had a huge focus on phonics, while the second school focused on whole language. There had to be a balance between the two. Just like there needs to be a balance between direct instruction and PBL. Or a balance between whole group and small group instruction. 1:1 isn't any different. Balance is key.

    Thanks for this post.

    Kind regards,
    Tracy

    ReplyDelete
  2. Jon,
    I wonder how we could combine these elements into an Agile fashion:
    -Good teaching
    -Professional Dev
    -Digital Citizenship
    -Parent involvement
    -Infrastructure
    -Sustainability
    -And the shiny new object!

    Where you are always delivering each of these as part of each feature, not, in a waterfall approach. Would make a great Definition of Done!

    John Miller
    http://theagileschool.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.